ShareThis
by Rodel Rodis
January 1, 2013
In a press conference held after she returned to Manila on December 22, Miss Philippines Janine Tugonon told embittered supporters who believe she was robbed of the Miss Universe crown by a hometown decision to get over it. “Miss USA deserved to win and I’m fortunate to place second among 89 contestants,” she said.
“Besides,” she added, “after what happened lately, America needs this win to boost its morale.”
What happened “lately” was the massacre of 20 school children and 7 adults in Newtown, Connecticut on December 14, just 5 days before the Miss Universe pageant in Las Vegas.
The Philippines could have also used the morale boost after Typhoon Pablo had left 710,224 Mindanao families homeless in its wake and had exacted a death toll 50 times more than were killed in Newtown.
But by refusing to be depicted as a victim of a hometown decision, Janine Tugonon exhibited humility, dignity and class. The same could not be said of Wayne LaPierre, the CEO of the National Rifle Association (NRA), who used a no-questions-asked “press conference” in Washington DC on December 21 to advocate for more guns, instead of less.
NRA apparently stands for “No Retreat, Advance” as far as getting more Americans to purchase even more firearms.
NO RETREAT,
ADVANCE
LaPierre laid the blame for the mass killings in Newtown on Hollywood which he described as “a callous, corrupt, shadow industry that sows violence against its own people”. He also blamed violent video games, music, the media, the courts, people with mental illness and “gun-free schools”.
Of course LaPierre failed to mention that all the factors he listed as responsible for the Newtown massacre exist in other countries as well. They watch the same movies, play the same video games and have their own share of mentally ill citizens.
In fact, on about the same say that Adam Lanza entered Sandy Hook Elementary School and shot and killed 20 students, Min Yingjun entered a primary school in Chengping, Central China and stabbed 22 students, ages 6 to 11. The difference between Chengping and Newtown is that all 22 Chinese students survived the attack because the Chinese assailant did not have access to semi-automatic firearms with high-powered ammunition as Adam Lanza did.
LaPierre’s solution to preventing future mass killings in US schools is to ask the US Congress “to act immediately, to appropriate whatever is necessary to put armed police officers in every school – and to do it now, to make sure that blanket of safety is in place when our children return to school in January.”
There are 99,000 public schools and another 33,000 private schools in the US. At an average cost of $50,000 a year in salary and benefits for each armed police officer, the NRA proposal would require Congress to appropriate $6.6 billion a year to implement it. This figure would not even include the cost of the training of the officers.
Training is vital as shown by the recent example of the New York police officers who responded to a gun shooting at the Empire State Building on August 24, 2012 and shot 9 innocent bystanders before they succeeded in killing the gunman.
FUNDING FOR
NRA DREAM ACT
It will be difficult, if not impossible, for Congress to appropriate the funds requested by the NRA since the NRA-backed Republican members of Congress have all signed the Grover Norquist pledge not to raise taxes. (Norquist’s publicly stated goal is to cut taxes to the bone to “shrink government to the size where we can drown it in a bathtub.”)
The funding for this NRA version of its “Dream Act” can only come by slashing and gutting Social Security, Medicare, Food Stamps and unemployment insurance.
Perhaps the NRA proposal should also include every place of worship to prevent the mass shooting that occurred on August 5, 2012 when Wade Michael Page entered a Sikh Temple in Oak Creek, Wisconsin and killed six worshipers and one responding police officer. As there are at least 95,000 churches in the US, this may require an additional allocation of several billion dollars.
Perhaps the NRA proposal should also include movie theatres to prevent the kind of massacre that occurred in Aurora, Colorado on July 20, 2012 when James Eagan Holmes threw tear gas grenades into a movie audience before using multiple firearms to kill 12 people and injure 59 others.
The NRA believes that if the movie patrons had been armed, they would have killed the shooter before the carnage occurred. But Holmes threw tear gas grenades before shooting, so how could the armed patrons have seen him? Would there not have been more people killed if every armed patron started shooting at who they thought was the shooter?
WILL ARMED
GUARDS WORK?
Placing armed guards in a school did not prevent the massacre that occurred at Columbine High School on April 20, 1999 when Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold shot and killed 12 of their high school classmates using semi-automatic weapons. There were two armed security officers at the high school and a deputy sheriff who arrived at the scene and exchanged gunfire with the shooters but they were unable to stop the massacre which only ended when the killers committed suicide.
How would the NRA explain the mass killing that occurred on November 5, 2009 at Fort Hood in Kileen, Texas when Army Major Nidal Hassan shot and killed 13 people and wounded 32 others? Virtually every soldier there was armed but it did not prevent the mass killing.
In contrast to the armed camp vision offered by the NRA is the example of City College of San Francisco where I served as an elected Trustee for 18 years from 1991 to 2009. City College has 110,000 students in 10 campuses, the largest of which is the main Ocean Campus with 38,000 students.
During my tenure at City College, we adopted a no-guns policy where our 40 campus police officers were not allowed to carry firearms while on patrol. The no-guns policy preceded my term on the board and has continued since then. During this entire time, there has never been any gun violence at City College which would have caused the board to reconsider its policy.
Although the NRA claims to represent 4 million members, a poll of NRA members revealed that an overwhelming majority of them favor background checks on gun buyers to determine their mental state and possible criminal/terrorist backgrounds. This is a policy opposed by the NRA
There have been at least 63 documented mass murders in the US in the last 30 years and in no instance was any mass murderer stopped by an armed civilian. As the New York Times noted, that fantasy happens only in the movies which, ironically, the NRA blames for propagating the culture of violence that breeds mass murderers. The NRA blamed everyone – the mass media, video games, Pres. Obama, the culture – everyone was at fault except the NRA.
Wayne LaPierre could learn a lesson in grace from Janine Tugonon. Instead, the NRA has fallen further in disgrace into what the New York Times called its “Hidey Hole” in Hell..
(Send comments to Rodel50@gmail.com or mail them to the Law Offices of Rodel Rodis at 2429 Ocean Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94127 or call 415.334.7800).